He's "Hot Priest"? I'm not so sure (6)
I believe the answer is:
helium
'he's' is the definition.
(synonyms)
'hot priest? i'm not so sure' is the wordplay.
'hot' becomes 'h' (abbreviation eg on taps).
'priest?' becomes 'eli' (Biblical character).
'i'm not so sure' becomes 'um' (expression of hesitation).
'h'+'eli'+'um'='HELIUM'
(Other definitions for helium that I've seen before include "Lightest noble gas" , "Light colourless gas used in airships" , "Balloon-filling element" , "Light colourless gas, sometimes in balloons" , "Second lightest element" .)